It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Subscribe to our Patreon, and get image uploads with no ads on the site!
Base theme by DesignModo & ported to Powered by Vanilla by Chris Ireland, modified by the "theFB" team.
Comments
No, the output of a guitar amplifier, even if only mildly overdriven contains strong HF harmonics that are 'filtered' by the poor HF response of the standard guitar speaker. Many a dad's tweeter has been burned out by even quite modest 'widdling' by an errant sibling.
Electrostatic drivers are no 'faster' than their moving coil counterparts*. What they DO have is very effective natural damping and low colouration. These qualities give them an excellent transient response. The same qualities are found in ribbon mics and tweeters and you do NOT want to put 20watts of HM thru an Adam monitor!
ICBM and other experts here are often telling us that 'hi-fi' technology is almost always the LAST thing you want in a guitar repro system!
*The 'speed' of any audio system is simply proportional to its bandwidth, the transducer type is unimportant so long as it can reproduce said bandwidth.
Dave.
Nil Satis Nisi Optimum
Even what YOU consider a 'clean' sound would be distorted horror to a hi-fi buff! This is largely because the SPEAKERS can reproduce the nasty harmonics.
If you can ever arrange to play guitar CAREFULLY through a wideband speaker you will find it sounds dreadful. This is why we have 'emulation' filters!
Fave.
Firstly it will sound terrible.
Secondly it will get expensive!
You *can* use hi-fi speakers in the same way as you would studio monitors, for reproducing a fully-speaker-emulated electric guitar sound at a low enough volume that it won't stress them, or for acoustic guitar (although it would still be wise to use a limiter).
I blew my first set of - luckily not very good or expensive - hi-fi speakers exactly by not knowing that at the time .
Although the odd thing is that I've discovered that I *do* like the sound of some - mostly semi-acoustic - electric guitars DI'd through a good PA, usually using the neck pickup. It can sound a bit like an acoustic guitar with a soundhole pickup.
"Take these three items, some WD-40, a vise grip, and a roll of duct tape. Any man worth his salt can fix almost any problem with this stuff alone." - Walt Kowalski
"Only two things are infinite - the universe, and human stupidity. And I'm not sure about the universe." - Albert Einstein
The advent of the active monitor and PA speaker has largely eliminated the risk to the drive units so long as the speakers are of high quality and have well designed protection circuits in the amplifiers. This will do nothing however to make a screaming lead guitar sound better! Your special case excepted IC.
There is also the fact that there are very few hi fi systems or monitors that can come close to the sound levels produced but even a 15W valve amp and a 100dB/W/mtr speaker!
Dave.
My my favourites are still the 57’s. But, don't put clamps on then, it kills their beautiful open tone.
Im on the look out for another set of Mark Levinsin Electrostatics, I don’t have the footprint for. 57’s any more.
are long gone. I still have a 22 and 2 pairs of II's. Using Rogers LS5/9 for years now.
Loved the Quads, but not for family life in small house.
Anyone ever turned a 22 into a guitar pre amp???
A lot of people my age started off playing guitar into Hi Fi's and radiograms because that's all there was. It used to sound terrible if you used any kind of overdrive or distortion, like a bee in a jam jar ! Clean sounds were also pretty uninspiring