Does this sound rubbish to you?

Clashman

30 minutes 59 seconds in ?

rustneversleeps

Gives me hope and I thought I was bad !

thecolourbox

Whilst it wasn't amazing I thought it was alright once he stopped talking absolute drivel, who was it?

steven70

k

ICBM

No, it sounds fantastic. Pretty accurate to the record actually.

One of the greatest songs from one of the greatest living songwriters.

If that doesn't move you, you either get it or you don't...

Funkfingers

Boggling slightly at a Socialist multi-millionaire, busking on a VERY expensive Martin guitar.

ICBM said:

One of the greatest songs from one of the greatest living songwriters.

To me, that video demonstrates why Waters and Gilmour are almost always better together than apart.

ICBM

Funkfingers said:

To me, that video demonstrates why Waters and Gilmour are almost always better together than apart.

That only applies to Gilmour .

Amused To Death is an outstandingly great album, and Is This The Life We Really Want isn't bad. The Pros & Cons Of Hitchhiking is OK but a bit too personal to be really powerful.

Pink Floyd without Waters was kind of OK-ish, if you ignored the songwriting...

Litterick

Thirty seconds was enough for me. Is the rest of it just as awful?

AustrianJohn

ICBM said:

Funkfingers said:

To me, that video demonstrates why Waters and Gilmour are almost always better together than apart.

That only applies to Gilmour .

Amused To Death is an outstandingly great album, and Is This The Life We Really Want isn't bad. The Pros & Cons Of Hitchhiking is OK but a bit too personal to be really powerful.

Pink Floyd without Waters was kind of OK-ish, if you ignored the songwriting...

The one you didn't mention - Radio KAOS - is my favourite Waters solo album.

Whatever they've done since then, back in the day they were brilliant together.