Is one or both of these gig bags fake?

paul_c2

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Fender-Traditional-Series-Gig-Bag-Electric-Guitar-/282130206344?hash=item41b0454e88:g:2loAAOSw1DtXHian

and

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Fender-Electric-Guitar-Gig-Bag-Soft-Padded-Case-With-Shoulder-Straps-/262589529494?hash=item3d238e3d96:g:NpoAAOSwTZ1XljSu

They're quite clearly different designs with different logo placement, which one (if at all) is real, or are they both simply cheap bags with a presumably non-Fender-approved logo stuck onto them?

thermionic

Probably both real, simply cheap OEM bags with a Fender-approved logo stuck onto them.

<edit> The first one looks legit at least. The second is possibly an earlier incarnation of their cheapest gig bag.

sticker

I had a Mexican thin line Tele that came new from the shop in a bag exactly the same as the first listing.

Skipped

Surely we now need a name for fake gig bags.
What about Chib Bag.
Does it sound too much like Chip Bag?

usedtobe

Chigbag, surely..?

Gagaryn

Both real I think - I've seen both designs come with mex Fenders

Alnico

Counter-fret ? To be fair i have only just woken up.

AndyR

Both look legit to me. If you've been buying cheap Fenders long enough, you'll have a loft-full of these things, all different.

MattFGBI

 I recognise both. 

ICBM

I assume Fender doesn't actually 'make' them, even in China - but just buys them from whichever standard high-volume Chinese bag supplier is doing the best deal that month/year. Hence you get different ones.

paul_c2

In the end I decided to buy a no-name bag, since there's nothing massively different or special about a Fender bag, apart from the logo. They all seem to be around £15-20 for a basic one, so I was able to choose one with 20mm padding. Also not having the Fender logo might be an advantage (less tempting to thieves??)