I was recently watching a yt video about Metallica's live right. They are a band I've always equated with jcm800s in their early days and boogie mk2s from there on.
I was surprised to see how it is all now solid state, axe FX preamps and solid state power amps being the order of the day. If a global act like Metallica has made the jump from all tube to solid state then I think the solid state tortoise is quickly closing in on the tube hare.
What is the element in how a solid state guitar amp sounds that when designers nail it the end for tube amps is conceivable ?
For me the tube amps give a 3 dimensional sound that solid state amps don't. Where the tube amp has the fullness in the low end married to the detail and spatiality of the high end, I've found solid state to sound flat and 2 dimensional. Imo when, not if, solid state amp designers. Solve that issue I think we will see a major shift in purchasing behaviours.
In your opinion what is the last piece of the solid state puzzle that when solved will shake things right up ?
Comments
When people start comparing the two blind I'll be more convinced by the comparisons.
But for me this conversation is fast approaching the "who really cares", use what works and sounds good to you, the digital stuff these days is really good. I need a new home amp and if a Katana fits the bill for cheap great, but I have the real deal at the factory that is load of fun to play through
I recently bought an old Musicman combo - the clean channel of the pre-amp is entirely sold state. It’s cleans sound better to me, than my all valve Lonestar Special. Received wisdom says this shouldn’t be the case - my ears tell me differently....
Which is why richardhomer's Musicman sounds like a valve amp, and a Marshall Valvestate doesn't even though they go some way to emulate it.
"Take these three items, some WD-40, a vise grip, and a roll of duct tape. Any man worth his salt can fix almost any problem with this stuff alone." - Walt Kowalski
"Only two things are infinite - the universe, and human stupidity. And I'm not sure about the universe." - Albert Einstein
Mega bands have also got touring down to an art where they have so reduced their tonnage to keep logistics costs down, that there's little motivation to lug fully laden 4x12 and 6x12 Marshall valve amps everywhere, especially when the house PA is doing all the work, and "tone" can be added at the desk. Volume is no longer Marshall stacks - which hark back to the days before PAs took over. That Marshall backline that Quo tour with? It's all empty boxes. Get over it.
Even in smaller venues, it's also about getting a balanced sound. You try having the patience to do that with your valve amps these days with so little time to set up before the gig. A PA with small portable desk makes setting up very much simpler, and as many older Fretboarders acknowledge, far kinder to the joints/ back/ aging muscles when clearing out after a gig. Not every band has a team of roadies to do the grunt work.
If it's a one off then it's the Columbia but a shlepp round the UK.....?
Before this debate goes any further can we establish a few ground rules?
"Solid state" amplifier. NOT a modeller (I'll get me coat!) . To my mind that way madness lies because digitals can be anything you/they want them to be. In my HO we are very close to a modeller that WOULD fool most people, most of the time on a 'DBlind A/B test.
"Valve" amplifier. Got to be I think TOTAL valve audio path? No ICs, no emitter followers (Boogie) . I think we must allow a Silicon rectifier if only because modern valve rects seem such shit?
The last one is tricky! Whilst I personally think a lot of "SState" designs would fool LISTENERS in DBA/B test I am not sure many would fool a seasoned player? Now, setting up a statistically valid DBA/B session for listeners is quite a task, doing so for the PLAYER such that HE does not know WTF he is playing might be nigh on impossible?
Anyone know of a suitable university, dripping with spare cash with Ugrads who can do the job?
Last thought. I doubt amp makers will donate/lend? Whilst many would LOVE to be told 'good as valve' not many would want the sobriquet 'no different from transistor'!
Dave.
I've just gone back to pedals through a lightweight SS head from a valve amp and I'm enjoying playing it. It does feel and sound different to my last amp but so do different valve amps.
https://youtu.be/nnYZ96DHo_g
And especially so if you’re going direct in the studio or to FOH.
https://youtu.be/nnT8_JRC8nA
Basically it’s already there, people just think of crappy solid state amplifiers from the old days and don’t realise how advanced newer stuff is.
Ive referenced Kemper here but it’s equally true of most modellers that use solid state power sections, ie the Axe Fx Rig Metallica use.
Feedback
I went to see Metallica on Saturday and the guitar sound was fantastic. I kinda wanted more bass (I always do with Metallica) as Rob is a stunning bassist, but overall the clean stage setup and more emphasis on a really great show and the work their sound guys did to upgrade the PA worked wonders.
It's hard, IMO, to have a heavy band not sound like mush. I've seen countless pro heavier bands just sound like bass drum/snare and a noise for guitars. Both guitars, especially the solos, were fantastic. The bass on For Whom The Bells Tolls worked perfectly.
I've gone all solid state for my bass gear after owning a really nice tube amp, because honestly, with bass I think headroom is more important and there are so many good bass overdrive/tube drive type bass pedals now that sound close to a good tube amp that no one ever knows, plus I can get the growl at a super low volume.
I've got guitar tube amps, but I bought a Boss Katana for home and for rehearsing and it's absolutely belting. I bought a Helix on a whim for both bass and guitar and whilst I don't have the time to enjoy it and I've put it up for sale, part of me thinks it is time to get to know it and just enjoy what it can do.
I have heard a lot of good solid state amps which don't use modelling, Tech 21 Trademark 60, Trace Elliot something or other combo, my own Fender Champ 110.
I wouldn't rate the Lonestars as particularly good examples of clean on a valve amp. I tried a couple of them when they first came out, and I thought the cleans were awful. The drive sounds were ok but finding a solid state amp with better cleans wouldn't be all that hard based on the ones I've played.
My feedback thread is here.
my Henriksen JazzAmp sounds amazing with an archtop or acoustic (bit to FRFR-like for solid bodies)
Also AER 60 is superb for electric cleans
Feedback