is Appetite for destruction the greatest debut album ever?

adampeter

discuss

SimonC

No

munckee

Made of Stone.  Close this thread please mods.

lysander

I don’t know but it’s certainly one of the best albums of all time, can’t think of any weak songs in there.
It was pure magic to me as a young teenager and massively influenced my learning of the guitar.

not_the_dj

Bjork surely. 

ICBM

No.

Black Sabbath is.

adampeter

munckee said:

Made of Stone.  Close this thread please mods.

Purlease 

mudslide73

I was talking about this on Friday with a work colleague. AYE?, VH1 and LZ1 are easily as good if not better. Appetite is a corker with no duffers though - it has to be said.

adampeter

not_the_dj said:

Bjork surely. 

lol

stimpsonslostson

Yes. Absolutely no doubt about it.
Best debut album. 
Best opening track ever too. 

Other contenders for best debut album are: 
Rage Against the Machine: Rage Against the Machine
& 
Nas: Illmatic

but Appetite is the best. 

bassbora

Yes. 




One of few 

munckee

adampeter said:

munckee said:

Made of Stone.  Close this thread please mods.

Purlease 

I said please! : )

scrumhalf

Appetite is better than Are You Experienced?

Really?

Better than Never Mind The Bollocks?

BloodEagle

Yes, Appetite or Beastie Boys - Licensed to Ill

sweepy

VH1 without a doubt

springhead

No it's not.  Are You Experienced, or Led Zeppelin 1.

Danny1969

Appetite is the most overrated debut album that's for sure !

camf

It'd be lucky to make top 100.

darthed1981

Great debuts?  Crikey...

Definitely Maybe

Suede

Generation Terrorists

Please Please Me

In any list of 100 great debuts I'd expect to see Appetite on it, great album, IMHO.

mrkb

Yes.....

TheMarlin

  Nope, it’s not even close to the album it ripped off. Most of the rifs were stolen from ‘Never Mind The Bollocks’ by The Sex Pistols.