It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Subscribe to our Patreon, and get image uploads with no ads on the site!
Base theme by DesignModo & ported to Powered by Vanilla by Chris Ireland, modified by the "theFB" team.
Comments
The owners daughter, is apparently a teacher, who had done her own research and thought it might be worth around 5k, which is what you arrive at if you do a search for Gibson Les Paul, either on Ebay, or Google, at todays NEW prices-roughly.
If you do the same search for a 50's LP you get very different figures, and this lady is a teacher?
Secondly, Mike at ATB goes to a lot of effort to say how bad the condition is, and hasn't even plugged it in, but has checked the pickups are re wired ( not re wound ), and claims the knobs are original.
The bridge posts are both 'snapped off', has anybody ever heard of this ? Could they have been cut off for some reason?
It has been re-fretted, and needs another ? This guitar was bought second hand for £50 in 67, and played for 3 years, then put in a case in the early 70's, had some sort of wiring mods done (pickguard switch ) and still has original strings from last play time?
It certainly had a hard life, but I would not consider it to be in 'bad' condition, let alone terrible, there is no buckle wear visible through the paint on the back, and the back of the headstock still has plenty of aniline colour-but the top is very faded, it would be nice to know some of the actual playing history here, what condition was it in when the owner bought it, and how much did he play / mod it?
In the vid, there is an LP hanging on the wall behind him which looks very similar, minus the Bigsby, I wondered if that was a Murphy maybe?
I know JB is no slouch when it comes to ID'ing these things, check out the video where he is asked to verify a V against one of his own at Norms, for an example of how astute he can be when looking at these things, he clearly had no qualms about this one, and I suspect it's condition is nowhere as bad as it is made to sound on the ATB vid.
I seem to recall even Eric paid £100 for his in 65, and he couldn't find another to replace Beano, so had to borrow the Summers burst, and Peter Green had bought the other one in the shop when he replaced EC in the Bluesbreakers, Beck had one around this time, Kossoff had a couple and there can't have been too many more in the country back then, so the owner got a bargain for his £50 in 67, something weird here maybe.
Just a few thoughts, still a nice story, and there's hope left in the world for the remaining undiscovered bursts to show up still.
I got to say I am skeptical too. The provenance for this seems very ordinary and convenient. The part about the guitar case I also know about too with dealers often keeping the case they came in to sell separately to get extra cash, I read that off this forum.
I will take the experts who has seen this at their word but like i said, I can't deny I am skeptical.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/joe-bonamassa-gibson-les-paul-b2078320.html
I love this stuff - especially when there are some Clouseau thoughts going on. Of which, I know attic and barn finds can often be grimy, but the one thing I found weird was how dirty it was considering it has been in its case.
I dug out my old art school portfolio when I moved last year. It spent forty years in house moves, under beds, in transit and the last fifteen in a dusty unlined attic. The prints inside were still pristine. Rubbish, but still in fine condition...
As for the price paid by ATB to the owner - absolutely confidential. It would be very bad form for a shop to publicly reveal information of that kind - for many reasons. The owner may want to surprise her family, or evade CGT, or not want her neighbours to know, or be doing a deal with the press etc etc.
Blimey, I feel uncomfortable talking £££ when trading on here - and that is small fry compared to this Les Paul. If the owner wants to shout out to the world, let her do it when she is ready.
Great thread !
I am not suggesting there is anything wrong with the guitar, only that some of the facts don't add up.
A well played guitar, when put in it's case for the last time, will not come out looking like it has been left hanging in a shed.
I have guitars on stands in my room, that accumulate dust, I have to dust them when I pick them up, the ones in cases are in the same condition they were in when I put them away.
JB knows his onions, and he didn't hang around, seems they all were happy with the transaction. Expect to see another Epiphone release ( probably with a Bigsby ) when he gets to tell his side of the story.
If I was in a position to buy one of these I’d want it sent to the lab to get some of it tested some how. Science has to be your friend here. If you cannot tell one from an original then it’s only the chemicals and compounds that will give it away
The world is full of people trying to have one over on you and some are extremely good at it.
Ok - perhaps you can address my biggest concern. How can a guitar that was 7 years old when bought have needed a refret and that refret is now worn out? Especially as he was an unknown guitarist, so presumably wasn’t playing every night and the guitar has been untouched since the early 70s. The photos don’t seem to show the sort of wear to the fingerboard edges and the playing surface I’d expect. Plus there wasn’t the pick wear on the bobbins/surrounds. And if nobody has touched the electronics, who disconnected the pickguard and switch.
Plus, how has it faded so much if it’s been in a case since 1970? Greenie was still quite red in 1967 through to 1970 - and that’s a matter of record. Greenie was also supposed to have been significantly more worn than the Beano burst and Beck’s slightly odd looking one. Then you see the back of this one that’s still very cherry…
This was a time when even professional players generally only had one guitar. They were played hard, left out most of the time, and generally treated as tools.
Judging by the condition, and given that it had been forgotten about by the owner, I would also imagine that this guitar has spent time, in its case, in a less-than-perfect environment like a loft or somewhere damp.
Internet sleuths trying to pick apart this story based on their own experience of storing cosseted guitars in a collection of many don't really have the credentials.
Joe B will have seen many Bursts in many different states and, if you know anything about his history on the Les Paul Forum, he can smell a rat from a mile off.
No need to be a pro player back then to do a shed loads of gigs - I'm 62 now and older FB members than me will endorse the story that back in the 60's and 70's you can sometimes do 2/3 gigs on a Sat night - Tea time slot - 8-11 and then finish in a late night bar - 3 gigs in 3 different venues - Then a Sunday mid day slot with another gig that night - Today many of us only carry out 2/3 gigs a month if that - 5-6 gigs a weekend back in the day was not unheard of - I can just about recall a Sunday lunchtime gig or two with a blues band
I suppose which area of the UK you live in, but I certainly recall many Derby/Nottingham based acts would travel to the North East for 2/3 weeks to do 10/20 gigs - And or the S Yorks area for similar amount of gigs in the social clubs